The Fanciful Arms of the American Church Union

Coat of Arms of the American Church Union
Rendered by Chad Krouse, 2025

During the Covid-19 pandemic, I came across the most unusual coat of arms online and knew I needed to save the image for future analysis.  I had completely forgotten about the arms of the American Church Union--an organization within the Episcopal Church--until recently when I was reviewing old files.  Don't adjust your screen yet.  

Fanciful and decadent arms?  Yes.  Incorrect?  Well, no.  Just busy trying to convey multiple references by using too many charges.  

The American Church Union was established in 1936 as the outgrowth of previous versions, this one dedicated for the "maintenance and defense of the doctrine, disciple, and worship of the Church, as enshrined in the Book of Common Prayer." 

Image of the American Church Union coat of arms
Image source:  Woodruff (1936, November 11), page 621

Above is the original image published in the The Living Church article written by Clinton Rogers Woodruff (1868-1948) who served as President of the ACU and an attorney from Philadelphia.  Woodruff was actively involved in furthering the Anglo-Catholic movement within the Episcopal Church.  

Advertisement appearing as early as 1912
in Living Church Annual (1912), p.467

Woodruff (1936, November 11) notes this newly formed ACU was the outgrowth of two previous unions, one from the 1860s and the most recent version from 1908.  The article does not supply a blazon or design rationale for ACU's coat of arms, only noting the arms were previously borne by one of the earlier unions and seen in use as early as 1912.

 Side by side comparison of the arms of the United States of America
and those of the American Church Union
Rendered by Chad Krouse, 2025

In the absence of any additional known data concerning the arms of the American Church Union, we can render a few informed guesses as to the design rationale.

These arms represent the state of heraldry in the Episcopal Church at the turn of the 20th century--the very purpose Pierre de Chaignon la Rose (1872-1941) saw in his heraldic work to correct by creating simple, clear, and perspicuous heraldry.  

First, we know by the dates involved these arms predate the 1940 adoption of arms of the Episcopal Church.  The lack of any unifying national symbol for the Episcopal Church in the earlier 20th century likely caused the designer to use the arms of the United States of America as the basis to show the organization's national scope.  I believe that much is quite clear when comparing ACU's arms with those of the US as seen above. 

Arms of the American Church Union
Rendered by Chad Krouse, 2025

Secondly, as to the charges on the cross quadrant, we're left to speculation as to their purpose.  Here's my working theory.  Given ACU's mission to preserve the 1) doctrine, 2) discipline, and 3) worship of the Episcopal Church in the Book of Common Prayer,  I think we can see a rationale beginning to emerge.

Doctrine could be illustrated by the seven red roses likely representing the seven sacraments of the Church, along with those three roses inverted surrounding the inescutcheon for the Holy Trinity.  The two gold bishop's mitres also likely represent discipline and authority.  For worship, I think, we see the blue fleur-de-lis in base which could represent the Blessed Virgin Mary and would strengthen the arms with a catholic purpose.

The blue inescutcheon with the Lamb of God might also be representative of worship, the heavenly banquet and aim of the Christian life.

I wanted to see if it was possible to revise the arms of ACU thinking and using those early mid-20th century resources for corporate heraldry.  Two possible revisions came to mind.

Two possible revisions for the arms of the American Church Union
Designed and rendered by Chad Krouse, 2025

The first idea of mine was to draw out the inescutcheon and work with the image of the Lamb of God while still incorporating the three ideas of doctrine, discipline, and worship.

Revision Example 1
Designed and rendered by Chad Krouse, 2025

Doctrine could be seen by the lamb standing on the barry wavy lines representing one of the many miracles Jesus performed during his earthly ministry--walking on water.  Discipline was again represented with the gold mitre of a bishop.  I liked the idea of the lamb embracing the mitre, showing the Church's tenderness and care for the ministry of the historic episcopacy.  

Pennon or flag designed by Chad Krouse, 2025
Click to Enlarge

I wanted the pennon or flag to show two references at once: creating a national symbol by placing the red and white bars horizontally to represent the flag of the United States and adding the chalice and host for both catholicity as well as for worship.  I felt this design gave a national symbol more readily recognizable to many by playing on the national flag.  

The chalice and host design has been used historically by Anglo-Catholic organizations and congresses, likely for the centrality of the Eucharist in the life of the Church.  I believe this image would also provide clearer references to ACU's catholic aims.

Admittedly, this design is still busy while attempting to simplify all the references made within ACU's arms.

Revision Example 2
Designed and rendered by Chad Krouse, 2025

The second idea emerged as my preference of the pair.  With this design, I wanted to strip away as much fussiness as possible with a clear and simple design.   

Side by side comparison of two design ideas
Designed and rendered by Chad Krouse, 2025

Using the arms of the US as the basis to form the bordure would provide a reference to the national scope of the organization, while the chalice and host in pale provides clear catholic identification which would likely have been known to many at that time.  I think it could be argued that doctrine, discipline, and worship can all three be represented in a singular "catholic," emblem of sorts.  I believe all three are implied.  Regardless, the chalice and host create a simple and clear design.  

Had the Episcopal Church's coat of arms been designed then,
here's an example of using those as the bordure.
Designed and rendered by Chad Krouse, 2025

I had two versions in mind here:  one to place the fleur-de-lis on the chalice playing on the Blessed Virgin Mary's role in the Incarnation (a very catholic position), or even more simply to have the monogram of the Holy Name placed on the host.

I think either would work, but the latter is becoming my favorite.

My favorite version of the revised arms of ACU
Designed and rendered by Chad Krouse, 2025

In summary, the arms of the American Church Union represent the state of heraldry in the Episcopal Church at the turn of the 20th century and underscore the need for a unifying national church emblem.

La Rose's emergence on the heraldic scene would help steer the fanciful impulses for heraldry towards a more simpler and dignified approach, employing a systematic framework for designing new corporate arms while establishing a standard for others to later follow.

Works Cited

Living Church Annual (1912).  The Living Church Annual and Whittaker's Churchman's Almanac.  Milwaukee: The Young Churchman Company. 

Woodruff, Clinton R. (1936, November 28).  An earlier Church Union.  The Living Church, 621-622.