Recent Posts

Thursday, September 5, 2024

Design Conformity: The Arms of the Episcopal Diocese of Washington, DC

Banners of arms of the Episcopal Church and the Diocese of Washington, DC.
Both arms were designed by la Rose.
Rendered by Chad Krouse, 2024
There stands out one coat of arms which drew wrath from the pen of Pierre de Chaignon la Rose (1872-1941) regarding the state of heraldry in the Episcopal Church. The heraldic designer from Harvard made his life's mission to correct the wrongs inflicted by arm chair heralds in the US during the early-to-mid 20th Century and set a new standard for corporate heraldry. The coat of arms of the Episcopal Diocese of Washington, DC quickly became la Rose's favorite target highlighting the gross misunderstanding shared by many Americans when designing arms.

Excerpt from la Rose (1907): 

Perhaps the worst of all, as even though unconsciously, the most impudent and misleading of American coats [Diocese of Washington, DC]...From the foregoing it will be seen: first, that the dexter impalement of the diocesan arms is an incorrect version of the arms of the kingdom of Jerusalem; and secondly, that in using these arms the diocese and bishop are guilty of a bit of heraldic assumption which even the Patriarch of Jerusalem or the Anglican bishop in Jerusalem would never dream of" (64).
In the same article, the heraldic designer proposed the following revision:

La Rose's (1907) illustrations published in his article.

La Rose's revision appears deceptively simply, yet this coat reveals a level of mastery already at work in his early heraldic career--combining all the desired elements and yet clearly providing geographical identification at the same time.
Coat of Arms of George Washington
Arms of George Washington.
Rendered by Chad Krouse, 2024.
The blazon la Rose created for his proposal:  Argent, two bars and in chief, between as many stars, a mural crown of five towers all Gules; on a chief Azure a Jerusalem cross Or (La Rose, 1907).
 
Arms of the Episcopal Diocese of Washington, DC.
Rendered by Chad Krouse, 2024.
Sometimes, however, those great designs cannot break through rife heralditis.  As such, the Diocese of Washington, DC would not take action on la Rose's proposal for 39 years.  During its annual convention in 1946 the Diocese would officially adopt la Rose's design (Chandler, 1946).  

Episcopal Diocese of Washington, DC banner flag coat of arms
Banner of arms for the Episcopal Diocese of Washington, DC
based on la Rose's design.
Rendered by Chad Krouse, 2024.
Now in 2024, some 78 years later, the design of arms for the diocese has not changed, proving la Rose's eye for sensible corporate heraldry.


Works Cited

Chandler, G.M. (1946 December).  Seal of the Diocese of Washington--1946.  Washington Diocese, 5-6.

La Rose, Pierre de C. (1907 November).  Ecclesiastical heraldry in America II.  Diocesan arms.  In R.A. Cram (Ed.), Christian Art, 2(2), pp. 59-71.

0 comments: